Why, when and how: Theory in Qualitative Empirical Studies
Graduate School of Health and Medical Sciences at University of Copenhagen
This is a generic course. This means that the course is reserved for PhD students at the Graduate School of Health and Medical Sciences at UCPH.
Anyone can apply for the course, but if you are not a PhD student at the Graduate School, you will be placed on the waiting list until enrollment deadline. After the enrolment deadline, available seats will be allocated to the waiting list.
The course is free of charge for PhD students at Danish universities (except Copenhagen Business School), and for PhD students at NorDoc member faculties. All other participants must pay the course fee.
Learning objectives
A student who has met the objectives of the course will be able to:
1. Identify and critically justify the choice and role of theory in relation to the research question, empirical material and analytical purpose of their own PhD project.
2. Compare and assess theoretical perspectives in terms of their assumptions, explanatory power, scope, compatibility and level of abstraction, and reflect on what different theoretical choices make possible to see and claim.
3. Distinguish between and critically assess deductive, inductive and abductive relationships between theory and empirical material.
4. Assess the coherence between epistemological position, theoretical framework, research questions, methods, analytical strategies and empirical material.
5. Apply theory reflexively in qualitative analysis and critically assess how theoretical choices shape interpretations, findings and the contribution of the research.
Content
Theory is central to qualitative empirical research, yet choosing and using theory is rarely straightforward. Why this theory rather than another? When should theory guide the analysis, and when should empirical material challenge or reshape theoretical assumptions? And how can theory be used to generate new insights rather than simply confirm what we already expect to find?
These questions are relevant throughout the PhD research process. Theoretical choices influence the questions we ask, what we are able to see in empirical material, how we analyse and interpret our data, and ultimately the claims and contributions we are able to make. Choosing and using theory is therefore not an isolated step in a research project but is interwoven with epistemological traditions, research questions, working assumptions, methods, empirical material, analytical strategies and the presentation of findings.
The course aims to strengthen PhD students’ ability to make informed and reflexive choices about why, when and how to use theory in qualitative empirical research. We will explore the strengths and limitations of deductive, inductive and abductive approaches and examine different relationships between theory and empirical material.
Participants will also work with questions concerning the status, compatibility, explanatory power, scope and level of abstraction of different theoretical perspectives. Drawing on examples from sociological and institutional theory, cultural theory, learning theory and patientology, we will examine how different theoretical perspectives open up particular analytical possibilities while potentially limiting others.
A central concern throughout the course is critical reflexivity. Theoretical choices, whether explicit or implicit, have implications across different phases of the research process. The ambition is therefore not to identify the “right” theory, but to strengthen participants’ ability to justify, apply and critically assess theoretical choices and their implications for qualitative empirical research.
Participants
The course is intended for PhD students conducting qualitative empirical research who are working with or in the process of developing the theoretical framework of their PhD project.
Participants are expected to have basic knowledge of theory of science and qualitative research. The course is particularly relevant for PhD students who are facing concrete questions about the choice and use of theory in relation to their research questions, empirical material and analysis.
Data collection should be in progress, as participants will work actively with their own research project and empirical material throughout the course. Participants are therefore expected to bring a theoretical question, choice or challenge from their own PhD project that they wish to explore and develop during the seminar.
A total of 25 seats are available.
Relevance to graduate programmes
The course is relevant to PhD students from the following graduate programmes at the Graduate School of Health and Medical Sciences, UCPH:
Public Health and Epidemiology
Medicine, Culture and Society
Language
English
Form
The course is organized as a three-day seminar, with a day in between reserved for participants to prepare their final presentations. The seminar combines lectures, discussions, practical exercises and workshops.
Two weeks before the course, participants are required to submit a one-page essay presenting their PhD project and reflecting on a theoretical question, choice or challenge relevant to their research. The preparation of the essay is estimated to correspond to approximately 7.5 hours of work.
The participants’ own PhD projects constitute central working material throughout the course. The essay will be used and developed across the seminar, enabling participants to move between general discussions of theory and concrete theoretical and analytical questions in their own research.
Participants will present and discuss their projects in small groups and receive feedback from course instructors and fellow participants. Through this process, they will critically examine and further develop the theoretical choices in their own research and consider how alternative theoretical perspectives might affect their analysis and interpretation of the empirical material.
Active participation in lectures, discussions, group work, exercises, project presentations and preparation is expected.
Course director
Anette Lykke Hindhede, senior researcher, Center for Health Research, The Capital Region, and professor, Department of Public Health, University of Copenhagen, anette.hindhede@sund.ku.dk
Teachers
Leslie Dubbin, associate professor, School of Nursing, University of California, San Fransisco, USA
Sasha Scambler, professor, Kings College, London, United Kingdom
Helle Timm, professor, University of Southern Denmark, Denmark
Camilla Bernild, associate professor, RUC, Denmark
Kristian Larsen, professor, Department of Public Health, University of Copenhagen, Denmark
Anette Lykke Hindhede, professor, Department of Public Health, University of Copenhagen, Denmark
Dates
10.-13. May 2027
Course location
CSS
Registration
Please register before 9 April 2027.
Seats to PhD students from other Danish universities will be allocated on a first-come, first-served basis and according to the applicable rules. Applications from other participants will be considered after the last day of enrolment.